Most enterprise coaching models cap dedicated support at director-level roles, leaving broader manager tiers with static coursework rather than real-time guidance during critical decision-making moments. Balancing 1:1, peer group, and emerging AI coaching requires clear evidence of what modalities truly work—and where research remains thin.
In this interactive session, leaders work through a manager scenario to compare what a human coach, a peer group, and an AI thinking partner each do well, and trade prompts and frameworks that make AI challenge a leader's thinking instead of simply agreeing.
Facilitated by Kyle Swanson, Jane Shlaes, and Thiago Oliveira, this session helps talent leaders decide where human judgment is non-negotiable and how to extend coaching to leadership tiers that rarely get it.
What we heard
Coaching rarely reaches managers below director level, so new leaders like Sarah, the session's example, ask AI for help, and AI built to agree can send them into a hard conversation sure they're right. Groups sketched a hybrid portfolio instead: triage up front, a human anchor through group, peer or certified coaching, and AI for practice reps, with prompts that challenge assumptions and point people back to their personal board of directors, HR or the employee assistance program. Thiago's challenge to every learning leader: follow your own development dollars, then decide whether to optimize for reach or depth.

"…you need someone that's going to challenge you. You need someone that's not going to accept your first answer."
Kyle Swanson
"…people cannot change by themselves. They need a supporting system to really be able to transform and to change."
Thiago Oliveira
